So! I finished reading John Green's
Paper Towns this weekend, and I liked it a lot. A lot more than the first third led me to think I might, in fact, and that's because it's a fairly thorough YA deconstruction of the Magical Rainbow Girl phenomenon (or what TV Tropes calls the
Manic Pixie Dream Girl. Now don't get me wrong; I can love a MPDG as much as the next person... if the author allows for her to be a real person, on some level. (
Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind: absolutely.
Garden State: not so much.)
(500) Days of Summer, though it had a lot I liked about it, irked me a little as it felt like the filmmaker, via Joseph Gorden Levitt's character, blamed Zooey Deschanel's Summer for being a real and fallible person beneath the MPDG exterior. Sorry, brooding, lonely men-children; a girl is not a monster for not idolizing you the way you idolize her. (I really like the plural "men-children," by the way.) Still, it's a common trope, and so when relatively straightlaced Quentin is dragged out of his window in the middle of the night for crazy, madcap adventures by a girl he's loved since he was nine, I sat back, ready for her to shake up his world until they realize they are perfect for each other, yay.
I underestimated John Green, it turns out. I don't want to spoil the book for you, as you should read it, but it turns out to be about a lot more than Quentin's relationship (or lack thereof) with Margo. One thing Green
really gets right is high school, both in its social dynamics and its psychology. So much so that parts of the book gave me the uncomfortable feeling I was back there. As I read it, I was picturing the halls of my high school, and even given the slight time gap, these kids talked like I remember high schoolers talking. He's actually a little weaker with true adults; both Q's parents and Margo's feel slightly caricatured at times. But the book has a momentum that propels it past any of its small flaws.
And it made me put a finger on something that's been bothering me about Cory Doctrow's
Little Brother, which I've been reading via
DailyLit. Not to pick on it; it's not a bad book. But something about Marcus, the main character, has been bugging me for awhile. And I think it's that Doctrow set up Marcus and friends as a foursome. Not just four kids who hang out together, but actual friends. The way Ben and Radar are Q's friends in
Paper Towns. But (and I haven't finished the novel yet, so take with a grain of salt) the difference is that not only has Doctrow separated Marcus from his friends, I seem to care more than Marcus does. Yeah, there's a little bit of angst, but he's distracted by his perfect, hot, nerdy, brave girlfriend who wants to have sex as much or more than he does. Ange (the girlfriend) has rubbed me the wrong way from the minute she showed up, and if Doctrow doesn't validate that feeling before the end of the book, I will be angry, because... well. What's satisfying with Quentin is that his search for Margo ultimately brings him closer to his friends (even making him a new one), whereas Marcus not only loses them, but is too busy with his cyberheroics and sexing up his girlfriend to notice. I grant you, the stakes in
Little Brother are objectively higher. But I think one of the problems I have with the MPDG phenomenon is that it perpetrates the myth that one person can be everything another person needs. That if you're in a romantic relationship with the
right person, you don't need friends or outside relationships, because that person is everything to you. And it's not only incorrect, it's dangerous to think that way. Mundanely, because you are certain to be disappointed. And in extreme cases, because it can lead people (of all genders) to accept emotional abuse because they think "that's how it's supposed to be."
To sum up, after this long digression,
Paper Towns is imperfect but enjoyable and thought-provoking. Definitely recommended. (And check out John Green's youtube project with his brother Hank, if you haven't already -
vlogbrothers always entertains me.)